The choice between a shower base and a tiled shower floor has become a pivotal decision for homeowners. Over recent years, tiled shower floors have surged in popularity, largely due to their unmatched visual appeal and the advancements in construction techniques that make them a practical and achievable option. Tiles offer a versatile range of styles, from sleek modern aesthetics to timeless natural stone designs, allowing homeowners to create a truly customised look that elevates the entire bathroom.
With waterproofing solutions and advanced materials ensuring durability and longevity. Builders and renovators now have the expertise to deliver shower tiled floors that are not only stunning but also functional, capable of withstanding the rigours of daily use. This combination of beauty and practicality has made tiled shower floors a go-to choice for those seeking to add a touch of luxury to their home or apartment.
Both options have their unique advantages and challenges, and the right choice depends on your personal preferences, budget, and the style of your house or apartment.
Material
Shower Bases
Shower bases, also known as shower pans, are typically made from materials like acrylic, fibreglass, metal or resign. These materials are pre-moulded into a solid, waterproof base that fits directly into your shower area.
Acrylic shower bases are one of the most popular choices due to their lightweight design, durability, and resistance to cracking or fading over time. They are also easy to clean and maintain, making them ideal for busy households.
Fibreglass shower bases are another cost-effective option, offering a similar lightweight structure but with slightly less durability compared to acrylic.
Metal shower bases are a distinctive choice for homeowners wanting an industrial or modern aesthetic. Typically made from stainless steel or aluminium, these bases are incredibly durable, resistant to corrosion, and easy to clean.
For those seeking a premium feel, resin bases are the top choice. Known for their sturdiness and luxurious finish, resin bases also provide a natural stone appearance that complements modern bathroom designs beautifully.
Today, you can choose from a wide variety of colours and finishes to match your bathroom’s style. Neutral tones like grey, beige, and charcoal are trending in Melbourne, while matte finishes are preferred for a contemporary look. Whether you want a sleek minimalist design or a bold colour statement, shower bases offer flexibility to suit your taste.
Tiled Showers
The main idea is that the tiles in the bathroom and shower are the same. Thanks to this there is no gap and inconsistency in the room design, everything is concise in the bathroom and shower tiled floor.
Tiled shower floors offer more versatility in terms of design, as they come in a wide range of materials, including ceramic, porcelain, and natural stone. Porcelain tiles are a popular choice for Melbourne renovations because they are dense, waterproof, and available in countless designs. Natural stone tiles like marble or granite create a premium aesthetic but require more maintenance.
Installation: DIY or Call a Builder?
Installing a Shower Base
If you’re considering a DIY bathroom renovation, a shower base is the easier option. Pre-made bases come in standard sizes and are simple to install with basic plumbing knowledge. Builders or renovators can complete the job quickly, reducing labour costs. The process involves leveling the floor, securing the base, and connecting the drainage system. Since shower bases are pre-waterproofed, there’s less chance of leaks.
Tiled Shower Installation
Installing a tiled shower floor requires more expertise. The process involves laying a screed to create the correct slope for drainage, waterproofing the area, and then meticulously placing each tile. Bathroom renovators often recommend professional installation to ensure the tiles are evenly spaced and the grout lines are sealed properly. Tiled installations demand attention to detail, making it a more time-intensive and labour-heavy option compared to shower bases.
Cost
Shower Base Costs
Shower bases are generally more budget-friendly than tiled floors. An acrylic or fibreglass shower base typically costs between $150 to $700, excluding installation.
High-end resin bases can go up to $1,500. Installation costs in Melbourne average around $300 to $600, making the total investment more predictable.
Tiled Shower Floor Costs
The cost of a tiled shower depends on the material you choose. Ceramic tiles are the most affordable, starting at $30 per square metre, while porcelain tiles range from $50 to $100 per square metre. Natural stone tiles can cost upwards of $150 per square metre. When you factor in labour costs for waterproofing, screeding, and tiling, a tiled shower floor in Melbourne can cost anywhere from $3,000 to $7,000 or more.
Durability
Shower Base
Shower bases are designed to last for decades when properly maintained. Acrylic bases are scratch-resistant but may discolour over time, while resin bases offer superior durability and maintain their appearance longer. With minimal seams, there’s less risk of leaks or mould growth.
Tiled Shower Floor
Tiled shower floors can also last for decades but require regular upkeep. Grout lines are prone to staining and cracking, and tiles can chip or loosen if the installation wasn’t done correctly. Proper waterproofing is crucial to prevent water damage beneath the tiles, especially in Melbourne homes where humidity levels can fluctuate.
Best for the Bathroom Renovation?
Shower Bases
Shower bases are gaining popularity among Melbourne homeowners looking for minimalist and modern bathroom designs. Matte resin bases in neutral tones like grey and beige are trending, offering a sleek and seamless look. Builders recommend shower bases for compact bathrooms in apartments, where space efficiency is key.
Tiled Showers
Tiled showers remain a favourite for those who prioritise aesthetics and customisation. Mosaic tiles, geometric patterns, and natural stone finishes are especially popular in high-end Melbourne renovations. Renovators note an increasing demand for underfloor heating in tiled showers, adding a touch of luxury to the bathroom experience.
Waterproofing Membrane
Shower Bases
One of the biggest advantages of shower bases is their built-in waterproofing. With no grout lines or seams, the risk of leaks is minimal, making them a reliable choice for both houses and apartments. Builders and Renovators often recommend bases for DIY renovators who want a hassle-free solution.
Tiled Showers
Waterproofing is essential when installing tiled shower floors. In Melbourne, building regulations require professional waterproofing to ensure compliance and prevent costly water damage. This process involves applying a waterproof membrane beneath the tiles, which adds time and cost to the project but ensures long-term durability.
Style and Design
Shower Bases
While shower bases offer fewer customisation options, modern designs now include textured finishes, anti-slip surfaces, and a variety of shapes and sizes. For minimalist Melbourne bathrooms, a sleek, low-profile shower base can complement contemporary interiors beautifully.
Tiled Showers
Tiled showers win hands-down in terms of design versatility. Whether you prefer classic white subway tiles, earthy natural stone, or bold geometric patterns, the possibilities are endless. Tiled floors allow homeowners to match the shower area with the rest of the bathroom’s style, creating a cohesive look that stands out.
Shower Base vs Tiles Floor
Ultimately, the choice between a shower base and tiles depends on your priorities. If you value affordability, ease of installation, and low maintenance, a shower base might be your best bet. On the other hand, if you are after a bespoke design and are willing to invest in professional installation and upkeep, a tiled shower floor is worth considering. Melbourne bathroom renovator can help guide your decision based on your specific needs, whether you are upgrading a compact apartment or renovating a spacious family home.
Choosing between a shower base and tiles is no small decision are all about blending style with practicality. By weighing up the factors of material, installation, cost, durability, and waterproofing, you can make a well-informed choice that suits your house, apartment, or DIY project.
Remember, whether you go for the sleek simplicity of a shower base or the timeless elegance of tiles, the key to a successful bathroom renovation lies in quality materials and professional workmanship.
